IMOS Mooring Facility QA, QC & Product Summit June 5-9, 2017

Background

This annual Australian National Mooring Network (ANMN) meeting is one of a series seeking to improve and where possible standardise QA and QC across the Moorings sub-facilities through common techniques, procedures and tools. It allows expert scientific, technical and operational staff – that is those actively involved in collecting and quality controlling the data – to get together to discuss the issues, swap methods and experiences to produce better data. 

The first two days a very much hands on training and inter-calibrating of techniques by the biogeochemical field samplers and laboratory processors. Wednesday and Thursday will focus on the time series data streams from the instrumented moorings. Experts have been invited to present on subjects relevant to the facility. Example troublesome data sets will be worked through – with a goal of producing a practical toolbox use protocol.  

An additional focus each afternoon will include a review of how best we can implement the production of growing long term time series products that will better service the research and wider user community. Approaches will vary for the very different data types: from monthly water samples and CTD profiles to scalar, vector and profiling moored sensor time series. There will be an assessment of what tools already exist and then a discussion to work out what developments are then needed to be worked on in collaboration with the AODN to produce a common tool.

We are excited to have speakers and attendees from the various operators across Australia, including CSIRO, the Australian Institute of Marine Science (AIMS), the University of Tasmania, the University of NSW, Sydney Institute of Marine Science, the University of Western Australia and of course the hosts South Australian Research and Development Institute (SARDI).

This meeting has broader application to facilities beyond ANMN and our ABOS cousins to others. Attendance is welcome form across IMOS as we want to draw on wider expertise. This particular summit is perhaps more inward looking than in the past in response to the challenge of producing more readily useable time series products to further promote and ease uptake by users.

Inputs & Outputs

There is flexibility in the program to allow participants to provide examples of troublesome or interesting data sets so that the wider group can learn from or help address issues raised. So if you have something you’d like to present please let Craig Steinberg and Guillaume Galibert know. Please continue to use the toolbox and moorings GitHub as they provide a way to share information, raise issues and seek help from facility members.

Through the meeting we expect to refine our methods that will update our user guides and also develop QC protocols. Recommendations will be made as to how best to provide the research community with improved access to quality data including the development of long time series products now we have a decade of observations.

Discussion on the merits of forming a separate Biogeochemical Steering Committee to the Moorings Steering Committee and Task Teams to look at Toolbox and data product developments.

Final Report

The report from the QC Summit 2017 is available for download here.

QC Summit 2017 summary of actions and recommendations is available for download here

Monday June 5th – National Reference Station BGC and CTD sampling

Session Chair: Claire Davies                                 Rapporteur: Carlie Devine

1300:  Welcome and round table introductions 

(Craig Steinberg, Ana Redondo-Rodriguez – 15 mins)

1315:  BGC manual updates modified NRS sampling (Claire Davies – 20  mins)

1335:  Video reviews + Group discussion  (55 mins)

1430:  CTD manual and assessment of regional capabilities 

(Tim Ingleton, Paul Malthouse & Michael Sutherland – 30 mins) 

1515: CTD lab session 

(Tim Ingleton, Paul Malthouse & Michael Sutherland– 90 mins)

Tuesday June 6th – SARDI & NRS Biogeochemical Sampling 

Session Chair: Ana Redondo Rodriguez                         Rapporteur: Carlie Devine

0900:  SARDI Capability (Paul Van Ruth – 15  mins)

0915:  Walking tour of SARDI (Paul Malthouse– 30 mins)

0945:  Hands on BGC and processing techniques (Paul Malthouse and Claire Davies – 45mins)

            Group discussion and work through sampling practical

1050   Hands on Biogeochemical sampling and processing techniques (continued – 60mins)

  • Practical example on water sampling and lab processing at SARDI
  • Sub-facilities to summarise what they are doing. Any other local variations? 

1150:  Microbiology sampling at Pt Hacking (Justin Seymour 10mins)

Session Chair: Claire Davies                         Rapporteur: Carlie Devine

1300:  Quality Control by Biogeochemical variable (Ana Lara-Lopez - 10mins + 5mins)  

1310:  Biogeochemical QC issues and data uptake  (Claire Davies & group discussion)

  • From field log sheets to database input. How IMOS flags are determined (~30mins)
  • Chlorophyll-a (Lesley Clementson) & TSS (Michele Skuza)
  • BYO issue/presentation. Request group for input/talks

1550:  The need for a biogeochemical Steering Committee? 

(Ana Lara-Lopez & group discussion – 15mins)

1605:  Biogeochemical sampling time series products (Claire Davies & group discussion)

  • How can we improve the uptake? Currently very basic outputs at present. Role of the AODN.
  • CSIRO are making products consolidated in spreadsheets– could include metrics, biological/chemical data. Monthly climatologies – roll out beyond to all NRS sites.
  • Ideas for data products how have people used it, which parts, why not using it? How to present the data? Identify other external users to get their input to improve. 

1640: CTD profile time series products (Ana Redondo-Rodriguez & Nicole Patten - 10mins+10mins discussion)

How can we merge water sample, CTD profile and time series?

Wednesday June 7th – Facility Overview and Sensor QC

Session Chair: David Hughes                                Rapporteur: Carlie Devine

0900:  Welcome and round table introductions    (Ana Redondo-Rodriguez – 15 mins)           

0915:  Annual Planning highlights (Craig Steinberg – 20 mins)

0935:   Facility updates & plans for 2017-19 (Sub-facility Reps – 5 x 10 mins + 5 min)

1050:  Biogeochemical days: summary of prior 2 days (Claire Davies - 10mins)

1100:  Quality Control by Biogeochemical variable (Ana Lara-Lopez - 10mins + 10mins)  

1120:  CSIRO Calibration facility update (Robert Kay – 20mins + 10mins discussion)

1150:  National and regional calibration & sample processing capability needs                                                                                                                    (Group discussion – 10mins)

1200:  Fluorometry to Chlorophyll-a?                                (Lesley Clementson – 30 mins)

Session Chair: Craig Steinberg                             Rapporteur: Carlie Devine

1330: The IMOS instrument and deployment database & user manual (Felicity McAllister – 15mins) 

1345: IMOS Toolbox overview – what’s changed/improvements (Guillaume Galibert – 15mins

1400:  Physical and Bio-optical sensor QC issues (Guillaume Galibert - 30mins)

1430:  Southern Ocean Time Series Bio-optical QC  (Christina Schallenberg - 20 mins)

1450:  Post –cruise reports and data QC (Ana Redondo-Rodriguez - 10mins + 10mins)

1510:  User provided data QC examples  (Group discussion and work through – 20 mins)

  • E.g. Low Conductivity in highly turbid waters

1550:  The value of long term time series from the IMOS AP NRS talks

1610:  Physical and Bio-optical sensor Product Development –growing time series (Guillaume Galibert -15 mins)

  • Context, what do we want and why, who & how can we do it?
  • Existing products AODN WQM burst averaged product & Temperature re-gridding          

1625:  Physical and Bio-optical sensor Product Development (Group Discussion- 35mins)

Thursday June 8th – ADCPs, extreme applications and workshop

Session Chair:  Moninya Roughan                                    Rapporteur: Emma Sommerville

0930:  Introduction to Acoustic Doppler Current Profilers (Craig Steinberg – 5mins)

0935:  Extreme application 1 – Large tidal currents, high turbidity backscatter (Simon Spagnol – 10mins)

0945: Extreme application 2 – Low oceanic backscatter (Nicole Jones – 30mins)

1015:   ADCP applications: modelling (Charles James, 15mins)

1130:  ADCP QC protocols by the ABOS (deep water) facility (Rebecca Cowley – 30mins)

1200:  ADCP QC issues (Guillaume Galibert and Group Discussion – 30 mins)

Session Chair: Charles James                                Rapporteur: Craig Steinberg

1330:  ADCP QC examples workshop (Guillaume Galibert – 60mins)

  • User supplied examples to be worked through
  • E.g. tidal harmonic analysis to check magnitude and clock settings

1430:  Existing approaches to producing long time series (Community presentation – 30mins)

1530:  ADCP Product development afternoon continued (Group Discussion – 90mins)

  • Context, what do we want and why, who & how can we do it?
  • Re-gridded Velocity products
  • Beyond Currents: Backscatter, Turbidity & Plankton abundance
  • Turbulence

 

Friday June 9th – Reprocessing: Automation, Expert QC and Production 

Session Chair: Craig Steinberg                             Rapporteur: Felicity McAllister 

0930:  Reprocessing: Automation, Expert QC and Production discussion (90mins)

  • Toolbox developments needed for the next decade.
  • Reprocessing – triggers, hot starts, automated (batch) vs expert (manual), recording reasons for flag allocation.
  • Access and archival of auxiliary data and files: raw data, calibration history, dropsheets
  • Review action items
  • Revive GitHub discussions
  • Product development (from minimal concatenation to create long time series to higher levels – e.g. a boundary current index.

1120:  Continued: Reprocessing: Automation, Expert QC and Production discussion (30mins)

  • Task team proposal(s)
  • NRS BGC Steering committee

1150:  Closing summary (Craig Steinberg – 10mins)